My dog is picky about his treats but he loves these and never gets tired of them. They are great for training, taking with you on long walks or hikes. They're not messy, don't crumble up in a bag, etc. There's no odor to them. A few go a long way. And according to Moxie, they taste great!
I send the Lucky Duck bits to my sister every few weeks and her Lab loooves them! Only thing that motivated her during training.
My two big dogs love them as training treats.
My dog loved the duck bits! They did harden up once they dried out, but she would still eat them.